FWP
Filed Pursuant To Rule 433
Registration No. 333-153150
January 8, 2009
|
|
|
WORLD GOLD TRUST SERVICES
|
|
Gold the supply side |
Gold the supply side
June 2008
George
Milling-Stanley
World Gold Council
Welcome to a World Gold Council Vodcast on Gold, the supply side.
The demand/supply equation
I talk to a lot of investors in the course of my work and I know how concerned many of them are
about the possibility of shocks from the supply side. With that in mind I want to devote a few
minutes to some thoughts about the supply side that is the bagel on the right.
Mine production
Here you have the primary component of gold supply, new production from mines, going back to 1997.
Production started to come off in 2001 and the trend has been generally downward since then. The
continued decline in mine production might seem a bit surprising given the strong rise in the gold
price over the same period, but it reflects the very long lead times that exist today in the gold
mining industry. It is also a legacy of the depressed gold prices during the 1990s when mining
companies simply couldnt afford to invest in their own future.
Reasons for declining production
Spending on exploration and development for new gold mines fell 70% from the peak to the trough
during the 1990s, so its hardly surprising that were not hearing a whole lot of reports of major
new discoveries. Exploration spending has picked up since then along with the rising gold price,
in fact Greg Wilkins, Chief Executive of Barrick, the worlds biggest gold mining company, told the
companys annual meeting recently that even though spending on exploration has recovered this is
not being reflected in really significant new discoveries. And Nick Holland, the newly appointed
Chief Executive of Gold Fields, told me recently that mining companies are becoming much less
choosey about possible gold deposits these days. Back in the day when I used to work for the
group, Gold Fields used to turn its nose at any deposit with less than 5 million ounces of gold;
now theyre happy to consider discoveries with as little as 2 million ounces.
Real production costs are rising
In addition, mining gold is an expensive business and its getting more so. The total reported
cost of extracting gold rose to just below $500 an ounce in 2007, from below $400 in 2006 and just
over $200 an ounce in 2002. And even those figures dont encompass the entire cost of running a
gold mining company. Quoting Nick Holland again, he told me that Gold Fields is now focusing on
what he calls Notional Cash Expenditure. What he means by that phrase is that the company counts
every single expense, whether its operating costs, capital expenditure, or indeed anything else
thats required to run a gold mine as part of its production costs. Nick estimates that if every
gold mine reported on that basis, something that hed like to see happen to persuade the industry
to get away from its present exclusive focus just on cash costs, real production costs in the
industry are probably averaging somewhere between $600 and $700 an ounce.
1
|
|
|
WORLD GOLD TRUST SERVICES
|
|
Gold the supply side |
Rising costs putting a higher floor under gold price
The increases in production costs reflect dramatic rises in many of the inputs into the mining
process. Energy is a key input, accounting for more than half of costs in some operations. The
costs of other raw materials, such as rubber, steel and cement, have also escalated in recent
years. Labour costs, yet another vital input, have continued their apparently inexorable rise.
From the standpoint of costs, theres a much higher floor underneath the gold price than there was
a few years ago. What does all this add up to? Most analysts are forecasting flat to declining
production for the next several years.
Recycled gold
The second element of gold supply comes from scrap or recycled gold. Scrap supply in any country
is determined by the price, and arguably even more by volatility in the price, in addition to the
nations general economic condition and the finances of every individual household. That makes
scrap supply inherently unpredictable, although Ive been impressed by one thing in our recent
quarterly reports of gold supply and demand and thats the way in which each fresh surge upward in
the gold price has triggered a wave of selling back, mostly in the emerging markets, but these
waves have been for the most part very short-lived, perhaps two weeks at most. And this is because
many potential sellers clearly believe the price is going to go on rising and theyd rather hold
off for a while to see if they can get a better price tomorrow or maybe even next month.
In the first quarter of this year scrap supply jumped by 30% from year earlier levels. This was
primarily due to consumers selling back jewellery in Asian and Middle Eastern countries as a result
of price movements. The melting of unsold inventory by manufacturers and retailers in North
America and Europe also continued; with gold prices this high, the trade simply cannot afford to
allow unsold inventory to remain on the shelves for very long.
The official sector
Moving on to the final element of gold supply, central banks. The official sector remains a net
seller, meaning that central banks contribute to the supply of gold each year. Of course the issue
doesnt get anything like the attention it received during the 1990s when investors were fearful
that any day might bring an announcement that yet another official sector institution had plans to
sell. The Central Bank Gold Agreement of September 1999 and its renewal in 2004 effectively took
this issue off the table as an area of concern for investors, bringing much needed transparency and
predictability to central bank dealing.
Central Bank Gold Agreement
Why were these agreements necessary? Many European countries hold a very large proportion of gold
in their external reserves. France, Germany, Italy and the Netherlands have between 55% and 70% of
their reserves in gold, while for Portugal and Greece the figure is closer to 90%. This is mainly
a historical legacy of the days when currencies were backed by gold when the world was on some form
of gold standard. The two successive Central Bank Gold Agreements have allowed several countries
that believed they held excessive quantities of gold to rebalance their reserves and to do so in a
transparent and controlled manner without causing any disruption to the broader gold market. The
signatories to these agreements are currently selling slightly less than their limit each year.
Will the agreement be renewed?
What will happen when the current agreement expires in September 2009? This has prompted a good
deal of discussion in the market over whether central bankers will decide to extend the
2
|
|
|
WORLD GOLD TRUST SERVICES
|
|
Gold the supply side |
agreement for a further period of years. The consensus of opinion among central bankers seems to
be leaning toward a renewal, but I must stress that these are personal opinions only. Its too
early for any of the signatory central banks to have taken an official position; it will probably
be the spring of 2009 before the market gets any meaningful indication of central bankers
intentions.
Possible IMF sales
Another development in the official sector during 2007 was the resurfacing of proposals for the
International Monetary Fund to sell some of its substantial gold holdings. But there are
significant differences between the current proposals and ideas that have been mooted in the past.
The IMF is now seeking permission from its members to sell a limited quantity of around 400 tonnes
of its gold in order to use the proceeds to establish an endowment, the income from which will be
used to finance the continuing operations of the IMF. The discussion over possible sales has
evoked little or no response in the gold market, the IMF has taken pains to minimize any potential
disruption. With this in mind, the Fund has emphasized that any sale would involve no net addition
to sales the market is already anticipating from the official sector because sales would be carried
out under the auspices of existing sales agreement among central banks. The sales would be
preceded by an examination of the possibility of off-market deals with other official sector
institutions, sales would be gradual and spread over several years, and the remaining 2,800 tonnes
of gold in IMF reserves would be ring-fenced to prevent speculation over the possibility of any
additional sales.
Summary and conclusions
To summarize:
|
|
Mine production: No reputable analyst seems to be expecting any significant increase in
mine production. In fact, most commentators seem to be looking for a flat to declining curve
for at least the next few years. |
|
|
|
Recycled scrap: In the absence of any significant economic distress, scrap is primarily a
function of changes in the gold price rather than the absolute level the price might reach.
Its not easy to predict, but it could be argued that the price may be in for a period of
greater stability after the exceptionally high volatility that has characterized the last 6
months. |
|
|
|
Official sector sales are expected to continue along the controlled, transparent and
predictable course central bankers have set for themselves. |
So, on balance, theres nothing to suggest that the market has any reason to fear a big surprise
from the supply side of the gold equation. Given some of the shocks the market experienced in the
1990s this should come as a great relief to investors.
For further information, visit the website at www.spdrgoldshares.com.
3
SPDR® GOLD TRUST has filed a registration statement (including a prospectus) with the SEC for
the offering to which this communication relates. Before you invest, you should read the
prospectus in that registration statement and other documents the issuer has filed with the SEC
for more complete information about the Trust and this offering. You may get these documents for
free by visiting EDGAR on the SEC Web site at www.sec.gov. Alternatively, the Trust or any
Authorized Participant will arrange to send you the prospectus if you request it by calling toll
free at 1-866-320-4053 or contacting State Street Global Markets, LLC, One Lincoln Street, Attn:
SPDR® Gold, 30th Floor, Boston, MA 02111.